1 | Adly
March 29, 2008 at 9:08 am

While the movie is less than inspired; it does bring up a few good points. What is more interesting is the reaction that it is provoking…. death threats, website suspension, and threats to anyone involved in it… so much so that no one wants to touch it with a ten foot pole. When books and movies come out that are less than flattering towards the other two major religions you mostly get a lot of complaints. Was the da vinci code banned due to death threats? Nope. If nothing else, this does show that Islam is inherently a violent religion. While the vast majority of Muslims may not agree with that aspect of the Quran, it is still there. The problem is that this book is seen as THE word of Allah(at least the suras). This makes discussing it and finding faults in it basically a sin. It is my opinion that Islam is at the same stage as Christianity was in during the middle ages. I just hope that it doesn’t take hundreds of years before an open debate can take place without death threats.

3 | nari
March 29, 2008 at 9:43 pm

maintenant les europiens sont enrage envers l islam ca montre leurs haine envers nous les musilmans la seul solution c est de les laisser aboiyer comme des chiens

7 | nari
March 31, 2008 at 11:18 pm

first you dont know about islam if you know it i am sur you will convert to islam like other s cristian catoluic and protestan this three old religions i advise you to read the holly book after that you can talk byyyyyyyyyyyyy

9 | qer_min
April 3, 2008 at 10:42 am

My personal instinct had brought me to write here.. First of all, i have to say that Quran cannot be read simply like that.. if you really want to know islam(not becoming one) you should read the quran WITH the help of one ‘guru’.. it’s like a small kid trying to read a university level reference book, you’ll misunderstood thousands of things.. so get a trusted ‘guru’ and start learning.. it’s not going to cost u anything to know a bit more about the world…and one more thing, u cannot judge Islam based on Muslim, because Prophet Muhammad had once said something like this… that at one time when the ‘qiamat’ nearly arrive, people of other religion will see Islam as a weak religion because Allah had taken out the ‘fear’ and ‘respect’ from others towards Islam.. instead, Allah had put the feel of ‘hedonisme’ and love of dunya into muslim’s heart.. (i’m sorry i can’t put together the source of Hadith, i’m only 17 and still have lots of things to learn) POINT NUMBER ONE:Muhammad(pbuh) said this during the peak of Islam.. He state that Islam will become weak one day even though at that moment Islam is the strongest religion, where they even managed to conquer Rome etc.. Current situation certainly proves his words, indirectly proves the rightness of Allah’s messenger… POINT NUMBER TWO: This also shows that at this time, it’s hard to find a muslim with ‘islam’ in his heart.. for that, we muslim call such people as mu’min.. there’s very little of such noble person that most muslim had been ruined.. hence PLEASE don’t judge ISLAM ONLY on the perception you made on the muslim in front of you.. Have you EVER known a Mu’min just yet?? POINT NUMBER THREE: from reading this you guys might even become misunderstood(again…) because it might sounds as if Allah is cruel for putting Islam at a lower point right now.. Well, this is actually not the case.. Actually this is a reminder to all Muslims out there at when ‘qiamat’ or the day of judgement is coming nearer, people will tend to forget their religion and solely focus on their wealth in this world.. (sekularisme is the most dreaded the thing ) This will cause Islam to fall, thus Muslims MUST defend their religion, especially the one in their ‘heart’… this though does not mean muslim MUST take their weapon and declare war though(see, sometimes even muslim misunderstood the Quran because they did’nt bother to refer to any ‘guru’ for answers…)but Islam must retain their stature with akhlak or attittude, unless they are attacked(in the case of Iraq) then only they are permitted to fight back.. Islam came from the word ’salam’ which means peace… for us to retain Islam in our ‘heart’, we need forces from ‘inside’ because the one thing that need to be change is something inside-the heart.. as the saying goes, the heart of a problem is the problem of the heart… thus we need to improve our self, construct the basis of Islam and put forward prophet Muhammad(pbuh) for example to follow.. Muhammad had once said i left the ummah(before he passed away) with two treasure, that if they follow this two they will never, NEVER got lost… If u read Quran and find thousands of verses that contradicts others, consult other mu’min to really understand the actual meaning,… this is because Quran is the greatest ‘literature’ found on Earth, and that no other poet can ever challenge Allah’s Almighty.. And if u have any question to ask about islam, please, don’t hesitate to ask me at arc_meen91@alwahy.com.. if i can answer them, i will, but if i can’t, i’ll consult my ‘guru’.. Honestly, i’m not saying that other religion are bad, but i found peace in practising islam.. despite what others said, such as it’s like a rule book that contains thousands of Do’s and Dont’s… but well, that’s life.. if you don’t have any rule in ur life, u’ll never find the right path, if u did’nt follow the law on the road, u’ll never end up having a safe journey.. Hopefully The Almighty will enlighten our life with his ‘hidayah’.. Peace be upon you..

13 | Armando C. Flores
April 11, 2008 at 2:12 pm

America is in denial. Do not Judge! claim the leftist in our country. Are we so inbecils that we can not see how this religion of the mohamedans is in a conquest? That’s right, in a conquest of the world by the sword all over again as in the 7 and 8 century. Why is it that americans are protecting and at the same time covering the terror and destruction around the world done specifically by mohamedans? Do you see Hindues bombing moeques? Or Jews or Christians destruing the idols of the Vetican? Do see any religion doing what the mohamedans doing in Africa, Sudan Indochina? For example killing, dismmemering children, men and women as this religion of hate do? No, a thousand times no. So then why are americans today afraid to say or hear the truth? What you see and hear in this film is what their book the so-called Quran is saying, become a mohamedan or be killed. Sura 8:60. Americans were once seekers of truth but now with all this influx of hispanic and estern socialist europeans and idigenous orientals in the last 60 years our poit of reference, the Bible has been lost. Who are the real villians in this film, the ones who report the atrocities commited by the mohamdans or the mohamedans themselves and their immams who insite this people? s your call.

15 | ahmad
April 28, 2008 at 6:53 pm

hi
I am an Iranian too. I read what Sarmad has written here. He is not right. He cannot speak as he is the representative of all Iranians. He didnt even check his English. I was so insulted when i heard about this film. It is against human right to insult a nation. i dont know why the UN hasent responded logically yet.